While most film genres rise and fall in popularity over the decades—we are currently in a mini-age of comic book action films—one genre stands head and shoulders above all others in durability: horror. This is often attributed to its ability to allow horror fans to experience fear, the most primal and visceral of human emotions, in a controlled manner.
But what fear are we talking about? Death? Financial failure? Loss of a relationship? Discovering that the cinema has run out of popcorn? No.
Fear of the monstrous
The common element of all horror films is that they address the fear of the monstrous. From its earliest moments, such as William Selig’s 1908 version of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde, horror’s archetypal villains have all been monsters or, like Dr Jekyll, humans with a monstrous side. Frankenstein, Dracula, the Hunchback of Notre Dame, Hannibal Lecter, Alien… the list goes on.
What is notable about this list is that monstrosity is almost always portrayed as masculine. What is monstrosity and why is it masculine? While some find death frightening, many welcome the opportunity to die with bravery, or at least dignity. What frightens us most is loss of dignity: ridicule, cowardice, sexual degradation.
In patriarchal societies, the sexual degradation of women is the ultimate nightmare. It demonstrates that the men have failed to protect the women—and hence the bloodstock of the tribe—from its enemies. While it may seem far-fetched, this idea remains at the core—consciously or otherwise—of all conservative ideologies.
Beyond the alien lifeforms and physical deformities so beloved of film’s early decades, at its core monstrosity is the shame of socially disapproved sex. This has historically taken many forms: sex across tribal or racial divides, between upper-class women and lower-class men, outside marriage, with more than one partner (jointly or severally), homophobia, anything other than the missionary position… The list is long but gradually being whittled down.
The monster represents the male attacker—whether it’s an outsider or a perverted insider—either violating women or expressing its sexual rage and disgust by murdering them
The horror genre reduces all of these socially shameful forms of sex to a single trope. The monster represents the male attacker—whether it’s an outsider or a perverted insider—either violating women or expressing its sexual rage and disgust by murdering them. For much of the 20th century the sexual element had to be sublimated, with death as its usual replacement. During the 1960s nudity gradually crept in, though displays of it remain limited in mainstream horror.
The poster for The Return of Dracula, a 1958 B-movie with Francis Lederer in the title role and Norma Eberhardt as the imperilled heroine, signals the key beats of the horror genre. Every element in the poster is included with singular purpose. Dracula is reduced to a cipher, an amorphous background blob whose only distinguishing feature is a single eye, curiously reminiscent of the eye of a penis. The dead man with a twisted face and a knife in his chest signals Dracula’s status as an alpha male who has the force to express all his impulses, violent or sexual, with impunity.
The ultimate horror
The foreground is given over to the title (ca-ching!) and to Rachel, a.k.a. the damsel in distress. Rachel assumes the same position as a submissive primate, her rear to the beast. Her skimpy dress rides up her thigh. A strap slips from one shoulder, hinting at nudity in an age when it couldn’t be put on screen without an outcry.
Even more provocative is her look back over her bared shoulder, a mix of fear and curiosity. While the prospect of being ravaged by uncontained masculine energy is frightening enough, what is truly horrific—from a patriarchal perspective—is the thought that Rachel might enjoy a good romp.
With the on-going march of female sexual empowerment—slut walks, the #freethenipple and #underboob Twitter campaigns—sexual shame is finally on the wane. It will be instructive to follow the impact of this on both the content and the popularity of the horror genre.